Ethring

Buffo - Saturday November 26, 2011 - 8:16

Thanks a lot for your feedback and also for your great tutorials, my maps would be way worse, if you hadn't written them^^

I've already done a few new maps (which are better than this one imo). However, they will be released together with our mod

_Haldir_ (Team Chamber Member) - Friday November 25, 2011 - 2:48

Really quite a good map, especially for a second try. The texturing is quite nice, it has an interesting layout, and there's some lovely object placement, especially around those smaller rivers that wind through the terrain.

The objects within the city are really nice, but could maybe use a bit of improvement. The buildings are all scaled quite large, which looks a little unrealistic, and doesn't leave much room for units to move through. I'd say it would look better if you added in more building, but have them all their normal 1.0 scale.
Also, there's a lot going on with the different types of buildings you have - there's Rohan walls, Gondor buildings, Corsair buildings, bits and pieces from Fornost, Grey Havens, Celduin and Dale.. It all gets a bit too much. It could be nicer if you were to restrict yourself to a few sets of buildings, so that the map has a certain style, rather than being a mish-mash of lots of different things.

All in all though, a decent map, and worth having a look at.

Buffo - Monday May 23, 2011 - 11:38

Feel free to criticize. Don't worry, I won't bite you ;)